Key vote on GET increase today

  • Hawaii County logo

Mayor Harry Kim started a public meeting on a proposed general excise tax increase Monday evening by reading a list of priorities he identified while speaking with residents during the last election.

There was public transportation, road and parks maintenance, county hiring practices, and, yes, even cutting taxes.


That last one has proved out of reach for the administration, which with approval of the County Council raised property and gas taxes last year to deal with budget shortfalls and lagging infrastructure.

Kim, during the meeting in Pahoa ahead of today’s do-or-die vote on a GET increase, noted while addressing the approximately dozen people present that he is now facing his “third strike.”

Still, he tried to win over skeptics of the one-half percent local surcharge, which the county can raise to fund public transportation and roads, by highlighting the expenses mostly out of the county’s control, such as collective bargaining unit raises that are negotiated statewide, and the need to get the mass transit system back on its feet.

“We need to fix our roads; we got to get our transit authority at least to the road to recovery,” Kim said.

“It’s a hard thing to ask three in a row,” he added. “Our choice is to fix it or let it stand.”

The council, while meeting as the Finance Committee, gave the surcharge a negative recommendation with a 3-6 vote. The bill can die today if it fails to get a majority vote in support. If there are enough yes votes, it will advance to a second and final reading.

Puna Councilwoman Jen Ruggles, one of the no votes, said during the Monday meeting that the tax increase hits low-income people the hardest.

“I believe there are options for more progressive taxes,” she said, while giving a tax on luxury homes as an example.

General excise is a state tax that applies to business activity and impacts everything from food to rental income. It’s currently at 4 percent for retail sales. The bill would raise that to 4.5 percent, with the last half-percent ending up in county coffers.

The county estimates that would raise another $25 million a year, with 30 to 40 percent from visitor spending.

For each $100 spent, shoppers will pay an extra 54 cents as a result of the increase, the county estimates.

Puna resident Bob Dukat said the tax shouldn’t exist in the first place.

“This is a slippery slope,” he said. “You open the door, and the mountain is going to fall in. The GET is a tax that should not be.”

Deanna Sako, county finance director, said the administration is looking to prioritize improvements to the mass transit system, which is in a state of disrepair and lacks functioning buses, if the tax increase passes.

Puna Councilwoman Eileen O’Hara said she supports the tax increase on the condition that the county also puts a hold on additional gas tax hikes.

“The GET puts us on track to actually plan for the explosive growth we have in Puna,” she said Monday evening.

Otherwise, painful cuts are coming, O’Hara said.

A resolution to stop additional fuel tax increases was postponed during Tuesday’s Finance Committee meeting. Council members said they wanted to wait until after the GET vote.

Additionally, county staff say the increase in fuel tax from 8.8 cents to 15 cents per gallon on Aug. 1 is bringing in less revenue than expected. While the county estimated an extra cent in tax would generate another $1 million a year, Aaron Brown, Public Works business manager, said the figure is closer to $850,000 because of lower consumption.

The county fuel tax is scheduled to reach 23 cents in the 2019-20 fiscal year, when it matches Maui’s rate.

The county administration is in the middle of planning for the next budget, which begins July 1.

Sako said it hasn’t been determined yet if any additional tax increases are going to be needed on top of the GET.

Kim claimed there is no fat in the $490.8 million budget after telling departments to tighten their belts. He also pledged to cut taxes in the future if the county can afford it.

Union negotiations aren’t the only reason expenses are increasing for the county. The county Salary Commission recently authorized large pay increases for administration positions and council members that adds $1.3 million to the budget.

The mayor and many top administrators got raises in 2014, while some others hadn’t seen a raise in 10 years. Salaries are mostly funded through property taxes.


The county has until March 31 to approve the GET increase, under the state law.

Email Tom Callis at

  1. Steve Dearing February 21, 2018 7:25 am Reply

    Only a foolish demo rat would believe a word lying Harry and the Council Bandits says. Lies, subterfuge and corruption is their specialty.

    1. Santas Claus February 21, 2018 10:00 am Reply

      Uh, Steve. Who had the road chip sealed with County money right up to your driveway? This tax increase is to pay for improving roads. Who’s been crying and screaming to get the dirt road to your property paved _by_the_county_, at the same time is rabidly against raising taxes?

      You complain about the druggies taking over. You complain about crime. But you don’t want to pay for police to take action.

      I really hate people that cry and scream about wanting stuff, but then don’t want to pay for it.

      You are a hypocrite Steve.

  2. Santas Claus February 21, 2018 9:54 am Reply

    Uh, Jen, what luxury homes on the big island? Your going to tax the few luxury homes to the tune of $25,000,000 to make up the budget shortfall? We already have the highest property tax in the state at over 11%.

    Your in lala land Jen.

    Wake up, for Christs sake.

    1. Scooby February 21, 2018 2:30 pm Reply

      So you’re fine with the insane raises these guys got that contributed to the budget shortfall and now tax increases? I’m all for paying my share of taxes for services but I’m not okay with increasing the pay of appointed staff while taxes need to be raised because of mismanagement and out of control spending by Harry.

      1. Santas Claus February 22, 2018 9:40 am Reply

        “Insane raises” brought them up to par with what other county councillors make. They are also getting part-time pay for a full time job.

        Granted there are some folks that got big raises that don’t deserve them. The raises should have been merit raises, not across the board as they were.

        I’ll also agree that Harry’s hiring lots of worthless contractors and paying them big bucks.

  3. Santas Claus February 21, 2018 10:14 am Reply

    All these people are against the tax increase, but when the cuts come, they’ll be screaming about the cuts.

    .. and Jen, who’s going to feel the most pain when the cuts come? Low-income people, that’s who. Your not protecting anyone.

  4. volcanovillage February 21, 2018 2:45 pm Reply

    mass transit system ???? oh….that is one heck of a system.
    A mass money losing system.

    1. burned_out February 21, 2018 3:23 pm Reply

      Hele-on means,
      Jobs for uncle, auntie, and cousin.

  5. burned_out February 21, 2018 3:30 pm Reply

    This is rich!

    “Kim claimed there is no fat in the $490.8 million budget after telling
    departments to tighten their belts. He also pledged to cut taxes in the
    future if the county can afford it.”

    A Democrat NEVER reduces taxes.
    No fat? I could spend 10 minutes and save you 10%
    of your budget. Today, now.
    I’d just ask a question, what do you need to do,
    and what do you want to do?

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Your email address will not be published. required fields are marked *

By participating in online discussions you acknowledge that you have agreed to the TERMS OF SERVICE. An insightful discussion of ideas and viewpoints is encouraged, but comments must be civil and in good taste, with no personal attacks. If your comments are inappropriate, you may be banned from posting. To report comments that you believe do not follow our guidelines, send us an email.